How to pick balanced teams for a football game
A game that ends 10–2 is no fun for anyone, not even the winners. Splitting into even teams is the organiser's hardest job: you have to be fair and not offend anyone. Here are the most common ways, with their pros and cons.
The 5 most common ways
- Captains pick in turn. Two captains pick one player each, in turn. Quick and everyone knows it, but the last one picked feels bad, and if the captains are the two best players the teams come out uneven anyway.
- Positions first. First split the goalkeepers, then the defenders, then the rest. Each team has a keeper and a defence: the way that best avoids a game that's decided from the start.
- By level. The organiser puts players in groups (strong, average, beginners) and splits each group in half. It works well, but you have to know everyone, and a ranking can start arguments.
- Fixed sides with rotation. The teams change every week by a rule (for example odd and even numbers on the list). Nobody picks, so nobody is offended, but the balance is down to chance.
- Random, then a fix. Random teams, then one or two swaps if one side is clearly stronger. Simple, but fixing it on the pitch takes time.
Rules that always work
- One goalkeeper in each team, before anything else.
- The two best players in different teams.
- Friends who always play together are worth splitting up now and then.
- If it's 5–0 after 15 minutes, one swap at half-time saves the evening.
- Split the teams before you get to the pitch: more playing, less talking.
Balanced teams in one tap in Squadiko
In Squadiko everyone picks their own team and position from the game's link. If the teams come out uneven, the organiser taps "Balance teams": Squadiko suggests two even teams that keep the positions (goalkeepers, defence, midfield, attack). Don't like the suggestion? "Shuffle". Players' strength stays private: nobody sees a ranking.
After the game players give medals to the best: a light way to recognise those who played well, without handing out marks.
Organise your game
Free, in 30 seconds: create the game, send the link to the group and everyone picks a team and a position on the pitch. Players don't need to sign up.
Organise your gameQuestions
What's the fairest way to pick teams?
Split the positions first (one goalkeeper per team, then the defence), then separate the best players. That most often avoids a game decided from the start.
How do you make sure nobody is offended?
Split the teams before the game, without picking out loud in front of everyone. In Squadiko everyone picks for themselves and the organiser balances in one tap; players' strength isn't shown.
What if the teams turn out uneven during the game?
One swap of two players of a similar level at half-time. Better to change straight away than play a game that's over after the first half.
More guides
An app to organise football with friends: how to choose one and use it
How to organise football with friends for free: one link to the group, everyone picks a team and a position, balanced teams, a waiting list and the cost.
How to find players for a football game (even at the last minute)
Short of players for your football game? Where to find them near you: friends of friends, local groups, the pitch, public games and a waiting list.
5, 7 and 8-a-side football: how many players you need and which formations to use
5, 7, 8 and 11-a-side football with friends: how many players you need, how many substitutes, the usual formations for each format and how to pick one.
How to organise a weekly football game
How to run a weekly football game without losing your mind: same pitch and time, a steady group, substitutes, the cost, reminders and who brings the ball.
The pitch cost: how to split it and get paid
How to split the cost of a football pitch between players and get paid without chasing anyone: how much to ask, when, cash or electronic payment.